Beating the Heat: How Advanced Evaporative Cooling Is Revolutionizing Pakistan's Poultry Farms

A simple, water-based technology is helping Pakistani farmers protect their flocks from deadly heatwaves, ensuring both animal welfare and food security.

Imagine being trapped in a thick winter coat during a relentless 45°C heatwave with no way to cool down. This is the everyday reality for millions of broiler chickens in Pakistan during the scorching summer months. Unlike humans, poultry birds lack sweat glands, making them extraordinarily vulnerable to heat stress. Conventional air-conditioning is prohibitively expensive, while traditional swamp coolers often fail when needed most. Now, innovative evaporative cooling technologies are emerging as a lifeline for Pakistan's vital poultry industry, offering a sustainable and economical solution to an age-old problem.

Why Can't Chickens Handle the Heat?

The vulnerability of poultry birds to high temperatures stems from their fundamental biology. As explained by researchers studying thermal comfort in poultry, "broilers lack sweat glands as compared to humans and undergo panting process to mitigate their latent heat (moisture produced in the body) in the air"2 .

This panting process is the bird's primary defense against overheating, but it becomes ineffective when humidity rises too high, creating a suffocating situation where heat dissipation fails1 2 .

The temperature-humidity index (THI) serves as a crucial measure of heat stress in poultry farming. Researchers have identified specific thermoneutral zones where birds experience optimal growth—straying beyond these zones triggers dangerous physiological responses1 .

Once environmental temperatures approach 47°C, the consequences can be fatal for the birds1 .

Critical Temperature Threshold

47°C

Environmental temperatures approaching this level can be fatal for poultry birds1 .

Three Revolutionary Cooling Technologies

Pakistani researchers have focused on three main evaporative cooling systems, each with distinct advantages:

Direct Evaporative Cooling (DEC)

The simplest and most traditional approach where air is directly exposed to water, causing temperature drop through evaporation. While effective, it significantly increases humidity, which can be problematic in certain conditions1 4 .

Indirect Evaporative Cooling (IEC)

A more advanced system that cools air without adding moisture through heat exchange. "The working air is cooled isenthalpically like DEC, and the cooling effect is transferred to product air by heat transfer between wet and dry channels"4 .

Maisotsenko-Cycle Evaporative Cooling (MEC)

The most innovative approach that "achieved THI threshold limit with reasonable temperature and humidity indexes" due to its breakthrough ability to theoretically cool air to the dew-point temperature, not just the wet-bulb temperature2 6 .

Inside the Experiment: Testing Coolers in Multan's Brutal Summers

Researchers conducted detailed experiments to evaluate these three cooling systems specifically for the climatic conditions of Multan, Pakistan—a region known for its extreme summer heat1 2 .

Methodology

The research team developed lab-scale experimental versions of all three EC systems with similar housing assemblies for comparable results. Each system contained:

  • A fan for air movement
  • Precision temperature and humidity sensors
  • Velocity sensors to measure air flow
  • Water storage tanks for the evaporation process
  • Specially designed cellulose cooling pads (for DEC)
  • Custom-built heat mass exchangers with separate dry and wet channels (for IEC and MEC systems)

The systems were tested under various conditions, with data collected specifically for Multan's climate, which features hot, dry conditions for most of the year followed by a humid monsoon season1 .

Results and Analysis: Which System Performed Best?

The experimental results revealed significant differences in performance among the three systems, with the MEC system consistently outperforming the others, particularly during the pre-monsoon extreme heat period1 2 .

Temperature Reduction Achieved by Different Cooling Systems in Multan

Cooling System April-June Temperature Drop (°C) July-September Temperature Drop (°C)
DEC 7-10 5.5-7
IEC 5-6.5 3.5-4.5
MEC 9.5-12 7-7.5

The MEC system's superior performance is attributed to its innovative design that enables "dew-point cooling"—the ability to cool air beyond the limitations of conventional evaporative systems2 . This breakthrough allows it to achieve greater temperature reductions without adding excessive moisture to the air.

Reduction in Temperature-Humidity Index (THI) Values

Cooling System THI Reduction (°C)
DEC 3.5-9
IEC 3-7
MEC 5.5-10

The THI reduction is perhaps even more important than temperature reduction alone, as it accounts for the combined effect of heat and humidity that determines poultry thermal comfort2 .

Performance Note: The performance of all systems notably declined during the monsoon season (July-September) due to higher ambient humidity, highlighting a limitation of evaporative cooling technologies in general1 . However, the MEC system maintained the best performance even during these challenging conditions.

The Researcher's Toolkit: Essential Components for Poultry Cooling Systems

Component Function Specifics Used in Experiments
Heat/Mass Exchanger Core cooling component Separate dry and wet channels for IEC/MEC; cellulose pads for DEC
Temperature & Humidity Sensors Environmental monitoring Precision sensors for ambient and supply air conditions
Air Velocity Sensors Airflow measurement Monitoring ventilation rates critical for poultry comfort
Water Circulation System Provides evaporation source Storage tanks and distribution systems
Fan Assembly Creates air movement Ensures proper airflow through cooling media and into poultry space
Data Acquisition System Records performance metrics Collects and analyzes temperature, humidity, and velocity data

The Bigger Picture: Sustainable Cooling for Food Security

The implications of this research extend far beyond immediate poultry welfare. With the poultry sector contributing approximately 1.4% to Pakistan's GDP and producing nearly 1.47 million tons of poultry meat annually, heat stress represents a significant economic threat1 .

Energy Efficiency

EC systems consume significantly less electricity compared to conventional compressor-based AC systems, making them more affordable to operate and reducing strain on Pakistan's energy grid4 .

Environmental Sustainability

Unlike vapor compression systems that use harmful chemical refrigerants, evaporative coolers rely solely on water as the cooling medium, leaving a minimal carbon footprint1 4 .

Economic Viability

For a developing economy like Pakistan, the low-cost and environmentally friendly nature of these improved systems makes them accessible to more farmers, helping to secure livelihoods and maintain food production2 .

International Recognition: A recent £2.8 million UK Research and Innovation grant aims to develop even more advanced cooling solutions for Pakistan, noting that extreme heatwaves in June 2023 resulted in the tragic loss of 120,000 lives and $16 billion in economic losses8 .

The Future of Farm Cooling

While evaporative cooling systems have limitations during humid conditions, ongoing research continues to enhance their effectiveness. The integration of solar-powered systems and smart monitoring technologies represents the next frontier in sustainable poultry cooling5 8 .

Current Systems

Advanced evaporative cooling (DEC, IEC, MEC) providing effective temperature reduction in dry conditions.

Near Future

Integration with solar power to reduce energy costs and increase accessibility in remote areas.

Future Development

Hybrid systems combining evaporative cooling with other technologies to maintain effectiveness during humid periods.

As climate change intensifies, the development of affordable cooling technologies becomes increasingly crucial—not just for human comfort but for food security and animal welfare. The success of advanced evaporative cooling systems in Pakistan's poultry industry offers a promising model for other heat-vulnerable regions worldwide, demonstrating how innovation can help both farmers and their flocks thrive in a warming world.

References